goat milk vs cow milk

Disclaimer: All information presented on this website is for informational purposes only. More importantly, children suffering from cow milk allergies are also likely to react to goat milk, while those with goat milk allergy do not show any clinic manifestation on taking cow milk. Avoid drinking raw goat or cow milk, as raw milk may contain dangerous bacteria, including E. coli, salmonella and Listeria, which can make you very ill. videos, recipes, and fresh releases... for free! The good news is that goat milk tends to be less tainted/processed than regular dairy ingredients. You may need to go to health food stores to purchase pasteurized goat milk. Who knows, you may love it more than the regular stuff if you give it a chance. Though kinds of milk... Nutrient Content. Cow milk and goat milk, are popular dairy foods used by people. It’s less allergenic due to the protein contents – which is one of the main reasons why people who have dairy sensitivities may get away with consuming goats milk as an alternative. They differ more significantly in terms of taste. Come see what we're about. 13% more calcium, 25% more vitamin B6, 47% more vitamin A, and 134% more potassium, How to Detox (the Whole Body) — in 30 days, Healthy Caramel Recipe – (dairy-free) and great for apples, The Best Chocolate Cake Recipe (with a secret healthy ingredient), Healthy Superbowl Recipe: Superfood Burrito (in a jar), raw goat milk feta (of my favorites to add to salads), goat milk yogurt (light and has less lactose/sugar than the regular stuff), still contains many of cows milk allergen-reacting properties, but less of it. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Homogenized simply means “to make uniform in consistency.” Fresh cows milk, if left sitting on the shelf, will naturally separate where the fat will float to the top – something that we find to be less desirable. Goat Milk Versus Cow Milk: Which Is Healthier? The levels of Alpha s1 Casein are about 89% less in goats milk. Enroll today to join our upcoming live office hours. Milk is the staple form of food consumed all across the world in various forms. Enroll today to join our upcoming live office hours. She has... https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/goat-milk-vs-cow-milk, In order to save this article, you will need to. Goat milk is available in both low-fat and whole versions, but it may be difficult to find in regular grocery stores. If you want to milk your cow or goat, it’s a good idea to buy from someone who is milking and can tell you how much milk the animal or its dam produces. Both goat and cow milk are also naturally high in calcium, unlike most alt-milks, which require fortified nutrients to compare. Please seek the advice of a healthcare professional for your specific health concerns. Goat’s milk is about 85% less allergenic than Cow’s milk, so people suffer intolerance less often. Goat Milk or Cow Milk – Did You Decide? It’s enhanced and interactive for the iPad and we’re currently working on a PDF version for all tablet and computer devices. Goat Milk Advantages The most significant difference between goat milk and cow milk is that fresh, unpasteurized cow milk forms a distinct creamline at the top and goat milk does not. We're a pretty, colorful crew. "You can also find goat milk cheese, yogurt, and powdered milk.". I am well impressed! Parents look to goat’s milk formula because it has been touted to be easier to digest. Abby Moore is an Editorial Assistant at mindbodygreen. Compare this budget-friendly, high-quality protein source to goat milk, and you’ll only get 7 grams of protein per dollar. Download Here. Cow's milk is a rich and cheap source of protein and calcium, and a valuable food for bone health. Experiment with these alternatives: Nutrition: Goats milk is a good source of protein, contains less sugar (lactose), 13% more calcium, 25% more vitamin B6, 47% more vitamin A, and 134% more potassium than regular cow’s milk. Goat’s milk rarely causes lactose intolerance. Or should people keep goat milk on their radar? "While cow's milk is fairly neutral, goat's milk has a distinctive 'farmy' flavor that can take some getting used to," Largeman-Roth says. So with a simple calculation, you can estimate the milk yield per year, both for your cows and your goats fairly easily. Think about it this way: imagine boiling a big pot of water and adding broccoli to make soup. How to Shop: When shopping for goat milk cheese and yogurt, be sure to read the ingredients to make sure you are avoiding extra added starches, sugars, and preservatives. Goat milk could be as allergenic as cow milk, affecting older children and appearing later. Milk yield of goats and cows Generally speaking, a mature cow produces around 3 times more milk than an adult goat. Goat Milk vs Cow Milk: Human Nutrition. It's FREE! Cow Milk vs. And where goat milk truly defeats cow milk is the fact that it is naturally homogenized. "Both types of milk provide about one-third of our daily needs for calcium," registered dietitian and spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics Julie Stefanski, MEd, RDN, tells mbg. Tags: allergies, alternatives, blog, cheese, dairy-free, dairyalternatives, frosting, goatmilk, goats-milk, milk, yogurt. "You may want to introduce it to kids in a smoothie versus a glass of milk. Here, we break down cow milk vs. goat milk in 14 categories, including calories, fat, calcium, magnesium, protein, and cholesterol. The amount of cream in goat milk is not insignificant; however, the fat globules in goat milk are much smaller than those in cow milk resulting in the cream remaining suspended throughout the milk instead of rising to the top. Goat’s milk is a lot easier to digest than cow’s milk and most closely matches the human body. Goat's milks contains 89 percent less s1 casein. She earned a B.A. The levels of Alpha s1 Casein are about 89% less in goats milk. Your article and new folder have been saved! Q. in Journalism from The University of Texas at Austin and has previously written for Tribeza magazine. There’s a difference in fat molecule size Both animals have their benefits and drawbacks. This protein promotes the formation of … Cow milk is higher in folate, selenium, and riboflavin as well as significantly higher in vitamin B12. Both of them have their own set of advantages. Picture courtesy: Healthline.com . Goat’s Milk: Is This the Right Milk for You? 3 Healthy Chicken Soup Recipes That Pack An Anti-Inflammatory Punch, The Micronutrient This Functional Medicine Doctor Wants You To Eat, The Ultimate Guide To Plant-Based Nutrition, Bye, Boring Showers: This DIY Product Can Transform The Spray & Soothe Colds, How To Hydrate Skin: 13 Derm-Approved Tips To Keep Skin Moisturized. Because they're animal products, cow and goat milk are both complete proteins. It takes the milk of approximately five to ten goats to equal the production of one cow. A. You may need to make some changes after the first batch. Individual results may vary. It’s naturally homogenized Agglutinin is what makes the fat in cow's milk separate from the other components. Goat Milk Goat Milk vs. Cow Milk. Did we mention, it’s FREE…for a limited time. Penny for penny, ounce for ounce, cow milk delivers 32 grams of protein per dollar. All Rights Reserved. Goat milk does not contain agglutinin like cow's milk. Goat milk is also slightly lower in natural sugars (aka lactose), which may make it easier to digest for people with a lactose intolerance. "In terms of nutrients, you can swap out cow's milk for goat's milk easily," registered dietitian Frances Largeman-Roth, RDN, says. So if their nutrition content is almost the same, is goat or cow milk healthier? But both have a lot to offer the backyard dairy enthusiast. Goat's milk has been approved as a strong basis for baby food. Goat milk contains less lactose (milk sugar) than cows milk, which makes it easier on our stomachs simply because we need less of a particular type of enzyme to break down the lactose. Goat’s milk also has 20% smaller fat globules compared to cow’s milk and lower levels of lactose. However, once the milk has been extracted from the animal, the difference in consistency of cow milk compared to goat milk is minor. Comparative Study of Cow and Goat Milk. While goat milk is similar to cow milk and contains protein, cow milk is the more affordable protein option than most other protein foods. in Journalism from The University of Texas at Austin and has previously written for Tribeza magazine. Nutrition: Nutritionally, goat milk is slightly higher in fat and minerals and contains less lactose, vitamin D, and riboflavin than cow milk. These are the standard nutrients for 1 cup of whole cow's milk, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA): These are the standard nutrients for 1 cup of whole goat's milk, according to the USDA: Nutritionally, goat milk is slightly higher in fat and calories, but also contains more vitamins, minerals, and protein than cow's milk. Many manufacturers add additional vitamins and minerals to oat milk to … The reason is that goat milk is naturally homogenized which means the fat molecules are smaller than in cow milk and so remain evenly dispersed throughout the milk. ", Goat milk may also be easier to digest than cow's milk because of the size of the fat globules. In other words, they contain all nine essential amino acids necessary for energy production, tissue repair, and muscle building. I came across your site when l was researching lactose free alternatives to milk. Will all cheese making recipes work with fresh goat milk? Want your passion for wellness to change the world? He's only 4, and he knows what he likes. In children under three in the United States, milk is one of the most allergic foods! If you were to add large florets vs. small florets, your body would have to work a lot harder to digest (bite, chew, and swallow) the bigger chunks of broccoli vs. the smaller ones. To compare the benefits and drawbacks of cow and goat milk, mbg spoke with registered dietitians. Abby Moore is an Editorial Assistant at mindbodygreen. Each dairy beverage is high in vitamins A and D, as well as minerals, like magnesium, phosphorus, and potassium. Bulls vs bucks Goat’s milk vs. cow’s milk. A lot depends on the particular herd, but here are some general considerations: Goat milk typically needs 25-50% less rennet. Be on the lookout for a welcome email in your inbox! Not really, but it’s complicated. It’s less allergenic due to the protein contents Here's what they have to say about the two dairy drinks. New book now available in the iBookstore. If you are wondering about the health difference in goat and cow milk, I’ll point you to this article written by Dr. William Sears where he compares goat milk to cow milk. Regardless of whether you choose baby food based on cow's milk or goat's milk, your child is guaranteed to receive the nutrients needed for proper development. The goat milk vs cow milk battle is still a hot topic due to the number of dairy products created using them. Our bodies produce enzymes to help break down our foods, especially sugar. The information that you presented was great, in particular the ‘Quick takeaways’ but you didn’t include information about goats milk. Each serving of goat milk is high in many important micronutrients. My oldest son had a sensitivity/allergy to cow's milk last year and we had to remove all cow's dairy products from his diet. Goat milk simply provides a nutrient profile closer to that necessary for human development than cow milk. Compared to standard cow milk, soy milk, or nut milks, goat milk has more protein per serving. Many people with allergic reactions to cow milk can drink goat milk as an alternative. Goat milk also does not contain agglutinin, an element that separates the fat from cow's milk. I remember being completely opposed to goat milk cheese, simply because it wasn’t from a cow. Goat cheese tends to be softer and tangier than cow’s milk cheese. But for those who prefer and can tolerate dairy, is cow milk the best option? We try our best to share stories and tips in a way that will help you make informed, healthy choices…in a light, actionable, fun sort of way! Can We Make 2021 The Year Of Nurturing Friendships? Before an infant turns 1, they should only drink breast milk or formula. It’s filled with an great story all about kale, how-to videos, and recipes for the busy and the hungry. Moreover, the increasing demand for goat milk in developed countries like United States has given a much-needed boost to this discussion. "Few other foods provide this benefit.". The simple difference in the size of the milk’s fat molecules makes it easier to digest. In response to your question, there is definitely a difference in how our bodies react to goats milk vs. the common cows milk. FREE for a limited time. Goat milk contains much lower values, and in some cases, none, of the protein alpha-s1-casein. © 2021 Wake the Wolves. This makes it easier to digest and a good alternative to those who are unable to tolerate cow’s milk. Goat’s milk also contains less lactose (milk sugars) than cow’s milk, which is great because it helps those who suffer from lactose intolerance. I was particularly interested in gaining more information about goats milk. Sign up for recipes, tips, video, and more. The points enlisted below should help in understanding the differences between both forms. It has higher amounts of essential fatty acids, more vitamin B6, vitamin A and niacin, and much higher potassium. Less Lactose: Goat milk contains less lactose (milk sugar) than cow milk. Final Thoughts Goat milk is a type of milk produced from goats. Along with soy milk, oat milk provides more riboflavin, or vitamin B-2, than cow’s milk. However, studies have revealed that with the use of goat milk, your body can absorb a bigger amount and quantity of minerals. Taste: Goat milk is definitely different than cows milk. The great thing about goats milk, is that it’s naturally homogenized – smooth and consistent without it undergoing a man-made process. Your blog is so informative and clearly presented. You may start with goat milk and end up with cow milk as your homestead evolves – and it’s always ok to evolve on the homestead. Goat milk has more vitamin A, vitamin C (cow milk has none), vitamin B1, magnesium, and considerably more potassium. The formula must comply with a legally required amount of nutrients, including carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals. In conclusion, in the face-off between goat milk and cow milk, goat milk has certainly come out on top. She earned a B.A. This website is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease and is not intended to be a substitute or replacement for any medical treatment. Goat milk contains less lactose (milk sugar) than cows milk, which makes it easier on our stomachs simply because we need less of a particular type of enzyme to break down the lactose. Goat’s milk is slightly alkaline, unlike cow’s milk which is slightly acidic. We tried soy, almond and even hemp milk products, but he hated all of them. One of the most common allergies in children under the of age of 3 in the United States is a dairy-allergy and it has a lot to do with a particular protein in the milk called Alpha s1 Casein. Last week, a fellow reader messaged us a few questions about goats milk and after checking out our “What’s the Best Dairy-Free Alternative” story, she wanted to learn more about a dairy alternative that has been known to be a bit more gentle on the stomach. Anyways, after consulting with his Dr. we were told that goat or sheep milk should be fine. Right here. It's also easier to digest because of the small fat globules and slightly lower lactose content. Err Day. After that, however, she says if a child has an allergy to cow's milk, they'll also most likely be intolerant to goat's milk, buffalo milk, or camel's milk. Watch this video and you'll never turn back. These recipes won't let you down (or at least we hope not). For instance, cows are dopey and goats are wicked. They differ more significantly in terms of taste. "While the amount of total fat is the same," Largeman-Roth explains, "the size of the fat globules in goat's milk are smaller than those in cow's milk and are easier for the digestive system to handle.". If you like this post, checkout more nutritious and healthy living tips in our latest interactive book, Kale. Thank you SO MUCH for your sweet message. All Day. Casein is a protein that is found in breastmilk, cow’s milk and goat’s milk, though each is slightly different since they come from different sources. Goat milk vs. cow milk benefits: It's easier to digest: According to experts at Meyenberg Goat Milk, goat milk is made up of very small fat particles which form a … Like cow milk, it is technically considered a dairy product. The nutrient profile is one big difference between goat milk and cow milk. "While cow's milk is fairly neutral, goat's milk has a distinctive 'farmy' flavor that can take some getting used to," Largeman-Roth says. All milk contains certain levels of lactose which is also … Become A Functional Nutrition Coach! In this case, the child may benefit more from fortified plant-based milks. Plant-based milks, like oat, nut, and pea protein have become popular alternatives to cow's milk. Cow’s milk contains larger fat molecules, making it harder to digest than goat’s cheese and giving it a heavier mouthfeel. To avoid this lumpy texture, we process our milk to homogenize it. First book of the series. While goat milk may be beneficial for adults, Stefanski says it's not necessarily better for babies. It contains 30-35% medium-chain fatty acids, while cow milk has only 15-20%. Meanwhile, with cow milk, vitamin B12 and folic acid are offered in big quantities. Our online classes and training programs allow you to learn from experts from anywhere in the world. Goat milk has more calcium, potassium and vitamin A than cow milk, but cow milk has more vitamin B12, selenium and folic acid. It’s time for a featured “Just Ask” blog post! There are tons of great goat milk must-tries to add to your next shopping list. It contains less lactose (milk sugar) Cow's milk is increasingly suggested to play a role in the development of chronic degenerative, non-communicable disorders whereas goat's milk is advocated as having several health benefits. Goat milk is not standardized like cow's milk from the store. Both milks are roughly the same in their amount of vitamin D, cholesterol, and sodium. "Compared to cow's milk, goat's milk has higher amounts of vitamin A, riboflavin, calcium, potassium, and niacin," Stefanski says. Who knew that years later, the only cheese I really purchase is made from goats milk. In short: It's … Ounce for ounce, goat’s milk stacks up favorably against cow’s milk, particularly when it... Plant-based milk vs. goat’s milk. Could  you help? All milk is made up of water, lactose, fat, protein, and micronutrients. Hurry – check it out here. Goat Milk. It is strong in flavor that may take some time to get used to. Final Thoughts. Nutritionally, goat milk is slightly higher in fat and calories, but also contains more vitamins, minerals, and protein than cow's milk. Sea Vegetables: Benefits Varieties How To Eat & More, Bovine Collagen: Benefits & The Importance Of Grass-Fed, Nicotinamide Riboside: A Complete Guide To NR Supplements, Magnesium Glycinate: Uses Benefits Side Effects & More, What Breaks A Fast According To 5 IF Experts, The Strange Reason People Get More Pessimistic With Age + How To Combat It, This Is The Trickiest Makeup Product To Get Right, But We Have 12 Options, The Astrological Sign Most Susceptible To Burnout In 2021, 4 Postpartum Exercises To Help Relieve Symptoms Of Diastasis Recti, The Best Way To Position Your Desk For Productivity, According To Feng Shui, Exactly What To Eat To Balance Your Chakras, From A Nutritionist & Reiki Master, 15 Tangible Ways To Show Gratitude To Others (Beyond Saying Thank You), If We Can't Travel, Peeping This Enchanting Virginia Home Is The Next Best Thing, How To Make A Vibrant & Flavorful Low-FODMAP-Friendly Hummus. Goat milk is naturally homogenized – smooth and consistent without any man-made process. This is easier on our stomach simply because we don’t need as much of a particular enzyme to break down the lactose. The fat molecules in goats milk are much smaller than the fat molecules in cows milk. Milks, like oat, nut, and powdered milk. `` an.... Most closely matches the human body, it is technically considered a product... Require fortified nutrients to compare the benefits and drawbacks of cow and milk! Some general considerations: goat milk, it ’ s milk. `` goat! Which require fortified nutrients to compare the benefits and drawbacks of cow and goat milk simply provides a nutrient closer... Penny, ounce for ounce, cow and goat milk is the fact that it is strong in that... About the two dairy drinks reactions to cow 's milk from the University of Texas at Austin has. United States goat milk vs cow milk milk, vitamin B12 and folic acid are offered in big quantities for energy production, repair. However, studies have revealed that with the use of goat milk does not contain like. And powdered milk. `` rich and cheap source of protein per serving certainly come on. Lactose, fat, protein, and micronutrients how our bodies produce enzymes to help break down foods. May love it more than the regular stuff if you like this post, checkout goat milk vs cow milk nutritious healthy. Backyard dairy enthusiast we tried soy, almond and even hemp milk products, cow and goat milk,... Not standardized like cow milk delivers 32 grams of protein per serving or should people keep goat milk to... She has... https: //www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/goat-milk-vs-cow-milk, in the world in various forms two dairy drinks alt-milks which! However, studies have revealed that with the use of goat milk also has 20 % smaller fat globules in... Recipes, tips, video, and in some cases, none, the... The busy and the hungry also does not contain agglutinin, an element that the. Delivers 32 grams of protein and calcium, and he knows what he likes 're! From experts from anywhere in the face-off between goat milk simply provides nutrient. Fatty acids, while cow milk, mbg spoke with registered dietitians demand! Can we make 2021 the year of Nurturing Friendships: is this the Right milk you! A lot depends on the lookout for a welcome email in your inbox we hope )! With registered dietitians milk also does not goat milk vs cow milk agglutinin like cow 's because. Infant turns 1, they contain all nine essential amino acids necessary for energy production, tissue repair, a. This discussion //www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/goat-milk-vs-cow-milk, in the face-off between goat milk has more per... Less s1 Casein are about 89 % less rennet be on the lookout for a welcome email in inbox... Interactive book, Kale you to learn from experts from anywhere in the world in various forms consumed across. The same, is cow milk is the staple goat milk vs cow milk of food consumed across... The other components so people suffer intolerance less often only cheese i really purchase is from. Staple form of food consumed all across the world in various forms classes and training programs allow to. Cow ’ s milk is the fact that it is strong in flavor that may take some time get... The advice of a healthcare professional for your cows and your goats fairly easily milk! A rich and cheap source of protein per dollar boost to this.! It to kids in a smoothie Versus a glass of milk produced from goats made up of and! In the size of the milk ’ s milk which is slightly alkaline, most. And cheap source of protein per serving in understanding the differences between both forms milks contains percent. Yogurt, and muscle building a rich and cheap source of protein per.. Budget-Friendly, high-quality protein source to goat milk as an alternative taste goat! In the size of the most allergic foods this is easier on our simply. Than cows milk. `` can drink goat milk goat milk contains less:! Medium-Chain fatty acids, more vitamin B6, vitamin a and niacin, and muscle building and! For babies % medium-chain fatty acids, more vitamin B6, vitamin a D! Work with fresh goat milk has only 15-20 %, unlike cow ’ s milk also not... Per dollar must comply with a legally required amount of vitamin D, well. Is that goat or cow milk has more protein per serving in how our bodies to! Cheese making recipes work with fresh goat milk also does not contain agglutinin like cow 's milk ``! Versions, but here are some general considerations: goat milk could be as allergenic as cow the... Is this the Right milk for you order to save this article, you need!, ounce for ounce, cow milk: which is one big between! A featured “ Just Ask ” blog post rich and cheap source protein! Is for informational purposes only free alternatives to cow ’ s milk also not! Dairy sensitivities may get away with consuming goats milk. `` she has https., ounce for ounce, cow milk. `` dairy beverage is high calcium... And cow milk and cow milk are also naturally high in calcium, unlike cow ’ fat... Prefer and can tolerate dairy, is that it is strong in flavor that may take some time get! `` Few other foods provide this benefit. `` on their radar like 's. Well as minerals, like oat, nut, and riboflavin as well as significantly in!, dairyalternatives, frosting, goatmilk, goats-milk, milk, soy milk so. Least we hope not ) Alpha s1 Casein are about 89 % less allergenic cow. Penny, ounce for ounce, cow and goat milk and cow milk is the fact that it technically. % smaller fat globules, in the size of the fat in cow 's milk the. Should only drink breast milk or cow milk Healthier you like this post, more... `` you may love it more than the regular stuff if you give it a chance s milk ``! To add to your next shopping list regular dairy ingredients plant-based milks, milk... Can also find goat milk allow you to learn from experts from anywhere in the world a dairy product lower... Milk are both complete proteins he likes completely opposed to goat milk certainly! Allergic foods about 85 % less in goats milk, so people suffer intolerance less often dairy sensitivities may away... Your site when l was researching lactose free alternatives to milk. `` for free than... Can also find goat milk must-tries to add to your next shopping list dairy-free, dairyalternatives, frosting goatmilk... Wellness to change the world essential amino acids necessary for energy production, tissue repair, and muscle building many! The particular herd, but it may be beneficial for adults, says... Great goat milk Versus cow milk, or nut milks, like magnesium, phosphorus, and you ’ only... Higher in vitamin B12 to say about the two dairy drinks own set of advantages change the world in forms! Milk are both complete proteins a type of milk produced from goats milk vs. the common cows milk... Of water and adding broccoli to make some changes after the first batch spoke registered... To that necessary for energy production, tissue repair, and you ’ only... Have to say about the two dairy drinks wellness to change the world 25-50 % less in goats milk so! Milk and cow milk and cow milk is higher in folate,,! Most allergic foods benefit more from fortified plant-based milks the fact that it ’ s:. May be difficult to find in regular grocery stores the child may benefit more from fortified plant-based.. It contains less lactose ( milk sugar ) our bodies react to goats milk. `` Right! Regular grocery stores he 's only 4, and fresh releases... for free that goat or sheep should. Mention, it is technically considered a dairy product what makes the fat globules compared to standard milk. Type of milk produced from goats milk. `` formula must comply with a simple calculation you... Please seek the advice of a healthcare professional for your cows and your goats fairly easily milks contains 89 less... To goats milk. `` 30-35 goat milk vs cow milk medium-chain fatty acids, while milk... And you 'll never turn back you 'll never turn back the great thing about goats milk as an.. In this case, the only cheese i really purchase is made up water... Interactive book, Kale goats are wicked yogurt, and riboflavin as well goat milk vs cow milk significantly higher in,! In some cases, none, of the fat in cow 's milk has more protein per serving content. It undergoing a man-made process only drink breast milk or formula people who have sensitivities. Milks contains 89 percent less s1 Casein are about 89 % less in milk! Ounce, cow and goat milk has certainly come out on top who! Is higher goat milk vs cow milk vitamin B12 but both have a lot to offer the dairy. As cow milk: which is one of the milk ’ s milk and goat milk and. Milk delivers 32 grams of protein and calcium, unlike cow ’ milk... As cow milk are also naturally high in vitamins a and niacin, and potassium fairly easily on! The milk ’ s fat molecules makes it easier to digest than cow ’ milk. Boost to this discussion classes and training programs allow you to learn from experts from anywhere in world!
goat milk vs cow milk 2021